Yellow Mustard is Now Available Online! Free Shipping on All Orders!

Our Story

"EDDIE, EDDIE, EDDIE"

Known far and wide for his grit on the football field, “Easy” Ed McCaffey’s tale took an unexpected turn, winding its way through the flavors of his childhood and the crisp mountain air.

As a former warrior of the gridiron, “Eddie Mac” found solace and joy in the simple pleasures of life, which included football, family, and, you guessed it, food. He loved good food and was constantly and curiously hunting for ways to make good food taste better. As the echoes of the cheering crowds faded, Ed set forth on a new journey. With encouragement from his wife Lisa and their four boys, he traded his jersey for an apron, fueled by a new passion for bringing his favorite flavors to the world. 

Ed's Mustard Masterpieces:

From Childhood Favorites to Gourmet Creations

Ed’s first creation was his “go-to” favorite spicy brown mustard, a nod to the flavors that adorned his childhood meals.  He remembered the days when turkey, chicken, and ham sandwiches were the cornerstone of his lunchtime rituals, and pretzels were his trusty companions.  Weekends at ballparks and football tailgates brought the sizzle of hotdogs, the savor of hamburgers, and the zest of brats, all adorned with golden brown goodness.

Spicy Brown Mustard was the 
game-changer that elevated his everyday simple meals to new heights.

It was more than a condiment to Ed; it was a companion, a culinary sidekick that rode shotgun on his gastronomic adventures; A reflection of the relentless spirit that defined him.  In many ways, Ed’s spicy brown mustard journey mirrored his own life – hearty, robust, and unapologetically flavorful.

On his quest to create his own very special recipe, Ed teamed up with renowned experts in mustard making and spent countless hours experimenting with ingredient combinations and taste testing.  The result was a classic yet uniquely flavorful spicy brown mustard with a creamy texture and “just enough kick but not too spicy,” said Ed.
Since that bold introduction, Ed has continued to craft an array of exceptional mustards, each a testament to his culinary prowess. His product lines boast a variety of tantalizing options, including Chipotle, Sriracha, Yellow, Honey, Creamy Dijon, and Beer Mustards. But that’s not all,  Ed’s creative genius extends to a delicious horseradish sauce, adding another layer of depth to his offerings.

As a former gridiron warrior, affectionately known as “Eddie Mac,” McCaffrey discovered solace and joy in life’s simple pleasures—football, family, and, notably, food. With an unwavering passion for culinary exploration, he constantly sought ways to elevate the flavors of his favorite dishes. As the cheers of adoring crowds faded into memory, McCaffrey embarked on a new adventure, trading his jersey for an apron, driven by a newfound mission to share his beloved flavors with the world.

Supported by the unwavering encouragement of his wife Lisa and their four boys, McCaffrey ventured into the culinary realm, fueled by a relentless determination to craft exceptional flavors that would delight palates far and wide.

Ed’s family, Lisa, and their four boys, are his greatest inspiration.

They’ve always encouraged him to follow his heart and chase his dreams, and they have filled their home with a lifetime of love and laughter.  Over the years, Ed and Lisa (ok, yes, mostly Lisa, haha) packed thousands of healthy and hearty lunches for their energetic and athletic sons, ensuring a blend of nutrition and flavor. The spicy brown mustard became a staple, making its way into sandwiches and onto hotdogs and burgers that fueled the boys through practices and games.

McCaffrey’s Rocky Mountain Mustard thrived in the market and became a symbol of the tight-knit family’s journey. Ed’s culinary passion, Lisa’s vivacity, and the boys’ athletic spirit blended seamlessly, creating a legacy beyond the kitchen. The spicy brown mustard, a testament to family unity, added a zesty touch to meals and memories.

The Rocky Mountains are where the McCaffrey Family calls home. Nature’s towering masterpiece deserves due credit for inspiring the creation of a man touched by their majesty, weaving their rugged beauty into the fabric of his creative endeavors.  So, when you dip into a jar of McCaffrey’s Spicy Brown Mustard, savor not just the flavor but the essence of the Rocky Mountains, where toughness meets taste in a dance that lingers on the palate like a fond memory.